Friday, November 19, 2010

Elaboration of a Mixed Idea

Let me elaborate on an idea me and my partner had from the activity in class. My passion was photography while his passion was the pursuit of knowledge. Our collective idea became the expression of knowledge through photography. So for example, it would be possible to express the Bystander Effect through a series of pictures. For context, the Bystander Effect is a social psychological phenomenon where the chance of help from a stranger diminishes with the amount of strangers in the vicinity of an incident. Photography could be used to show the different stages of this phenomenon through a series of pictures. For instance, one picture could have a a single person help another person up from falling on the ground. A second photograph would have several people looking at a fallen person, but nobody helping. A third photo would show a lot of people merely offering a glance in the direction of the fallen person.

The presentation of the photographs is also an important detail worth going into about. They could be done with a slideshow, but that would be a bulky solution which would follow the pace of the presenter. A more efficient presentation would be a comic format, with several cells of pictures adjacent to one another. This would let the reader go at their own pace with a clear direction for viewing, i.e. left to right.

The reason photography might be a better solution than a simplified graphic would be to show the reality of the explanation, as the subject of photography will always be a real situation frozen in time. A graphic might get the point across a little easier, but chances are it will stick more if there were an actual picture instead. A good photograph just tends to stick in the mind; probably because humans were made to remember pictures of the world and our past. Digital graphics do not offer this kind of picture as they are too simplified and unrealistic.

3 comments:

  1. Your idea of mixing photography and the desire to obtain more knowladge is extremly interesting and i think you the way you described how real pictures of our world hold mor meaning in our own minds than simple cartoonish images that we could create otherwise. The only problem that could be forseen with such a combonation is the question of how would you portray mathamatics in pure pictures. I know you are only offering this picture knowladge as an addition to a humans methods of obtaining information, however, i sometimes like to think of situations in the extreme.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a cool idea. I appreciate the originality in it and I think it would be an interesting way to learn. However, it seems like if pictures were the only source from which you were supposed to learn, if it is not backed up with words, it will be more common for people to interpret them slightly differently. therefore general ideas might be easily conveyed but it would be difficult to teach a person completely new ideas through pictures, as every individual would interpret it a little differently than the artist intended. And, as John said, how would you present math? :P

    This is a very interesting idea, though, and I think it could work well as a learning tool combined with others.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can really relate to your passion of photography and I believe that pictures can really tell you a lot of things and definitely can be used to spread knowledge. I also feel your point that photography is critical and digitally generated graphics can never be compared to photography and are not that useful becuase they lack the reality that photographs contain. I have a passion for taking photographs of wildlife and my dad and I do a lot of traveling in various wildlife parks in the United States and in India. There is definitely nothing like capturing a picture on a camera.

    ReplyDelete