Specifically, the missing basics Goldberg talks about are the inability to ask questions, label key ideas and subjects, model the solution, decompose the problem, measure, visualize ideas and implementations, and effectively communicate with others on a project. Understandably, these are skills a traditional education would simply skip over in favor of the core math and science. This is an obvious problem, as engineers need to not only know the subject they are dealing with, but how to apply it efficiently and cleanly as well.
During this semester, I wish to develop the following three skills to benefit me in my future engineering endeavours:
- Better communication. Of course I know how to talk, but when it comes to sharing abstract ideas, simply making sounds out of my mouth only goes so far. I need to learn how to break my ideas down into simple parts that others can easily understand. I plan to learn this skill throughout college as there will always be times where I need to speak with peers in a subject to give or receive help.
- Improved planning. It is easy to get away with procrastination and last minute action during a small personal project. With a larger project involving others, planning is essential. The lab portion of ENG198 is great for this as the two projects lend themselves to the development of planning skills easily.
- General engineering ideas. There may come a time when I need to communicate with other types of engineers. If that ever occurs, I better have a solid general engineering foundation so we can converse on equal terms. This goal should be achieved through going into engineering classes and clubs. I plan to do this throughout freshman year at least.
I agree that communication is a very important missing basic and liked the way you compared it to a bridge for engineers minds. I would have to point out that I feel there is yet another key component to math, science, and communication, and that is creativity. In math and science there is often little room for more than problem solving. While math and science problems sometimes require some creative work they do not use nearly as much as would be needed by an engineer trying to create something new, or trying to build something that is not covered in text books.
ReplyDeleteI like that you want to work on your planning skills but I don't feel that the lab portion of this class is the best way to improve them. I the ENG 198 lab all of our time is pretty well allotted for us. Very little to no work has to be done outside of class. I would suggest that if you wish to improve your planning skills you could try to start on homework the day you get it, and try to finish it before the day it is due. I do think that our iTeams will be a good way to work on just about all these skills, planning and communication especially.
You have a compelling thesis statement. You make a good point that being an engineer is more than just crunching numbers. They need good people skills and the ability to work well with others. Social and planning skills are good improvements to better yourself as an engineer or in any field of work.
ReplyDeleteYou did a good job in your post listing the different aspects of the missing basics and how you plan to implement them in your life. I also feel like you made a good point by stating that an engineer today is not the number crunching, specialized worker of the cold war. That's why I was enticed by engineering, I want to create something and do something useful besides sitting behind a desk all day working calculations. Today, an engineer is expected to communicate with others and work strongly with a team in order to succeed. The lab is a good start, and I feel the course will prepare us for this in a way that traditional mathematics and science courses would not. An engineer needs to present their inventions or work in a simple and understandable way. I think that all of the goals that you chose work towards this end and are a good target for you and for anyone in the workplace.
ReplyDeleteI would have to agree with you about your views on communication in the engineering world today. From my experiences of working with real-life engineers, I think that the communication aspect is just as important as the design aspect. Being able to effectively present your idea is crucial to being taken seriously, so it is a good plan to want to improve your presentation skills.
ReplyDelete